The Smoke and the Fire: Myths and Anti-myths of War, 1861-1945
Worth buying if: You enjoy military history that questions orthodoxies and looks past battlefield folklore.
Skip it if: You prefer exhaustive campaign-level detail, unit diaries, or blow-by-blow battle narratives.
Exact edition: Edition shown · ISBN-13 9780850523300. The Amazon link uses this ISBN, so the product page should open to the edition shown here.
If this page helped you decide, purchasing through the Amazon button above supports UPB Books at no extra cost to you and helps us continue improving the site. Thanks for visiting today.
Check Amazon for the current price and availability of this exact edition.
Affiliate disclosure: purchases made through links on this site may earn us a commission at no additional cost to you.
Summary
John Terraine dismantles popular assumptions about strategy, technology, leadership, and morale across conflicts from 1861–1945, blending concise narrative with pointed critique of military legend-making. He shows how myths shaped policy and public memory, often to disastrous effect.
Why this book now
As debates over military history and public memory intensify, Terraine’s brisk myth-busting reminds readers why accuracy matters when past lessons shape present choices.
30-second preview
Two quick cards, fifteen seconds each.
Card 1 of 2
Best for readers who...
Good fit if you want...
- You enjoy military history that questions orthodoxies and looks past battlefield folklore.
- You want readable, evidence-driven essays rather than long operational chronicles.
- You prefer exhaustive campaign-level detail, unit diaries, or blow-by-blow battle narratives.
- You want a highly partisan or celebratory account of any single nation’s wartime record.
- You need the newest edition, freshest examples, or the most current framing.
Decided it fits?
Exact edition: Edition shown · ISBN-13 9780850523300
Worth buying if: You enjoy military history that questions orthodoxies and looks past battlefield folklore.
Skip it if: You prefer exhaustive campaign-level detail, unit diaries, or blow-by-blow battle narratives.
Check Amazon for the current price and availability of this exact edition.
Reader guide
Cues to help you decide faster.
Reading commitment
Balanced Moderate time
At 240 pages of tight, essayistic chapters, this book is accessible in short sittings yet rewarding if read straight through for the through-line critique of myth-making.
What stands out here
This Pen & Sword edition preserves Terraine’s concise arguments and archival references; readers looking for newer scholarship should pair it with recent studies but will find his core challenges still resonant.
Best way to approach it
Read selectively by chapter to sample specific myths, or read cover-to-cover to trace how myths recur and mutate across wars and generations.
Was this page helpful?
Quick thumbs only. No login.
Loading feedback…
Exact edition: ISBN-13 9780850523300
Check Amazon for the current price and availability of this exact edition.