An Excellent Mystery
Worth buying if: You savor Ellis Peters’ Cadfael puzzles rooted in monastic life and mercy.
Skip it if: You prefer forensic gore and breakneck action over abbey halls and quiet deduction.
Exact edition: Edition shown · ISBN-13 9780786222698. The Amazon link uses this ISBN, so the product page should open to the edition shown here.
If this page helped you decide, purchasing through the Amazon button above supports UPB Books at no extra cost to you and helps us continue improving the site. Thanks for visiting today.
Check Amazon for the current price and availability of this exact edition.
Affiliate disclosure: purchases made through links on this site may earn us a commission at no additional cost to you.
Summary
In An Excellent Mystery, Ellis Peters sets Brother Cadfael amid The Anarchy, where two monks arrive with secrets linked to a noblewoman who disappeared. Cadfael’s herb‑garden wisdom and quiet logic unravel vows, identity, and murder without breaking faith or heart.
Why this book now
Cadfael’s 12th‑century compassion and cluecraft read like a calm antidote to noisy thrillers—An Excellent Mystery remains a series high point worth rediscovering.
30-second preview
Two quick cards, fifteen seconds each.
Card 1 of 2
Best for readers who...
Good fit if you want...
- You savor Ellis Peters’ Cadfael puzzles rooted in monastic life and mercy.
- You’re drawn to The Anarchy’s chivalry, lost betrothals, and identity riddles.
- You prefer forensic gore and breakneck action over abbey halls and quiet deduction.
- Medieval church politics, Latin chants, and gentle pacing leave you cold.
- You are specifically hunting for the newest framing rather than a backlist perspective.
Decided it fits?
Exact edition: Edition shown · ISBN-13 9780786222698
Worth buying if: You savor Ellis Peters’ Cadfael puzzles rooted in monastic life and mercy.
Skip it if: You prefer forensic gore and breakneck action over abbey halls and quiet deduction.
Check Amazon for the current price and availability of this exact edition.
Reader guide
Cues to help you decide faster.
Reading commitment
Balanced Moderate time
At 299 pages, this mid‑series Cadfael case rewards an unhurried weekend, best read in a few reflective sittings.
What stands out here
This Thorndike Press edition features large‑print formatting, giving Peters’ clean prose and period detail extra ease on the eyes.
Best way to approach it
Settle into the cloister: follow names, vows, and timelines closely, linger on Cadfael’s herb‑lore and motives, and let the emotional reveal arrive without rushing.
Was this page helpful?
Quick thumbs only. No login.
Loading feedback…
Exact edition: ISBN-13 9780786222698
Check Amazon for the current price and availability of this exact edition.